
The College Football Playoff selection committee released its third Top 25 of the 2026 season Tuesday night, and Max Chadwick agrees with much of the order.
Not all of it.
Georgia staying at No. 1 makes sense. Utah at No. 2 does too. The biggest problem begins immediately after them, where the committee continues to rank two-loss Alabama ahead of undefeated UCLA and several teams Chadwick believes have stronger cases.
There are also questions farther down the rankings, particularly with South Carolina remaining in the Top 25 after a 28-point loss to Arkansas.
Here is the committee’s latest order and where Chadwick would make changes.
Latest College Football Playoff Top 25
Georgia Deserves To Stay No. 1
Chadwick has no objection at the top.
Georgia improved to 9-1 by beating Missouri 48-21 and has looked increasingly dominant as the season has progressed.
PFN’s strength-of-record metric had the Bulldogs fourth when Chadwick recorded his reaction, so this isn’t simply a case of one résumé metric lining up perfectly with the committee.
Chadwick’s argument is based on how Georgia is playing.
“They look like the most dominant team in college football right now,” Chadwick said.
The Auburn loss remains the obvious blemish, but Georgia has answered it by consistently overwhelming quality opponents.
That is enough for Chadwick to keep the Bulldogs first.
Utah Has a Legitimate Case for No. 1
If there is an argument against Georgia, it comes from Utah.
The Utes are 10-0 and remain one of only two undefeated FBS teams. They also sat No. 1 in PFN’s strength-of-record metric at the time of Chadwick’s breakdown.
Utah has beaten BYU, Houston, and Arizona and has avoided the type of slip-up Georgia had against Auburn.
PREDICT THE CFB SEASON:PFN’s Free CFB Playoff Predictor
Chadwick still prefers Georgia based on dominance, but he would have no issue with anyone placing Utah first.
The important point is that the committee has the correct two teams at the top.
Alabama Is Far Too High at No. 3
This is Chadwick’s biggest problem with the rankings.
Alabama is 8-2 and remained No. 3 after beating Vanderbilt 21-6.
Chadwick doesn’t believe the Crimson Tide should be above UCLA. He doesn’t believe they should be above Notre Dame or Miami. He would also put Texas ahead of Alabama and gives Tennessee a strong case because of the head-to-head result.
“I don’t really understand why Alabama is right now getting a first-round bye in the playoff,” Chadwick said. “I don’t even think it should be hosting a playoff game in the first round.”
PFN’s résumé metric had Alabama eighth during the recording, much closer to where Chadwick believes the Crimson Tide belong.
Alabama’s two losses came against Georgia and Tennessee, so neither is especially damaging in isolation.
The issue is comparison.
UCLA is undefeated. Notre Dame and Miami each have one loss. Texas owns one of the strongest collections of ranked victories in the country. Tennessee beat Alabama directly.
For Chadwick, that is too much evidence to keep Alabama third.
UCLA Should Be No. 3
Chadwick would move UCLA into Alabama’s spot.
The Bruins are 10-0 after beating Illinois 22-14. Their schedule has not been as strong as several other contenders, but Chadwick doesn’t believe that should erase an undefeated record in the Big Ten.
There is also a significant difference between saying UCLA hasn’t played an elite schedule and saying it hasn’t beaten anyone.
The Bruins have continued winning every type of game placed in front of them, with one of the best defenses in the country providing a stable foundation every week.
At this point, Chadwick believes 10-0 deserves more weight than Alabama’s stronger schedule with two losses attached.
Notre Dame and Miami Should Both Be Higher
Texas moved from No. 6 to No. 5 after beating LSU 22-21.
Chadwick understands the ranking.
The Longhorns are now 5-0 against teams ranked in the committee’s Top 25, giving them more ranked victories than anyone else in the country.
The problem is the losses.
Texas lost to Oklahoma and Florida, two teams outside the top 20. Notre Dame and Miami each have only one defeat.
DIVE IN:PFN’s Free CFB HQ — Team and Player Stats, Info, and More
Chadwick would therefore move Notre Dame to No. 4 and Miami to No. 5 before getting to Texas.
Notre Dame also owns the head-to-head win over Miami, giving the Fighting Irish a simple argument for staying ahead of the Hurricanes.
Texas remains comfortably inside Chadwick’s playoff field. He simply wouldn’t have the Longhorns fifth.
Tennessee’s Win Over Alabama Should Matter More
Tennessee sits ninth, six spots behind Alabama.
That gap is difficult for Chadwick to justify when both teams are 8-2 and Tennessee beat the Crimson Tide by 16 points.
The committee does not rank solely by head-to-head results, nor should it. But when two teams have the same record and broadly comparable résumés, the direct meeting should carry significant weight.
Chadwick would rank Tennessee ahead of Alabama.
He would also consider moving Indiana higher than eighth after the Hoosiers improved to 9-1 with a 27-13 win over USC.
The result is a top nine that looks substantially different from the committee’s even if most of the same teams remain involved.
BYU, Wake Forest, and Texas Tech Could Decide the Final At-Large Spots
The most interesting cluster begins at No. 10.
BYU is 10th, Wake Forest is 11th, and Texas Tech is 12th.
Chadwick believes Texas Tech may be getting the least respect of the three.
At the time of his reaction, PFN’s résumé rankings had Wake Forest ninth, Texas Tech 10th, and BYU 11th.
BYU’s biggest advantage is obvious: The Cougars beat Notre Dame.
Texas Tech and Wake Forest have only one loss apiece, however, and both remain in excellent position to reach their respective conference championship games.
That is where the problem could emerge.
If Wake Forest and Texas Tech both finish 11-1, lose their conference championship games, and BYU finishes 10-2 without playing for the Big 12 title, the committee may have to choose two teams from that group for the final at-large positions.
Chadwick doesn’t see an obvious answer yet.
The next two weeks will probably provide it.
Oregon, Ohio State, and Iowa Are About Right
Chadwick has fewer complaints about Nos. 13-15.
Oregon is 13th after moving up three spots. Ohio State jumped six places to 14th. Iowa remained 15th.
Oregon has three losses but owns head-to-head wins over Ohio State and Boise State, which gives the Ducks a strong argument to remain ahead of both.
Ohio State at No. 14 also makes sense to Chadwick.
Iowa fans may want the Hawkeyes higher at 8-2, but the résumé lacks a major victory. Chadwick pointed out that Iowa has yet to beat a team with a record better than 6-4.
That keeps the Hawkeyes in the middle of the Top 25 rather than near the playoff cut line.
Boise State Could Be a Little Higher
Kentucky fell five spots to No. 16 after losing to Florida. Boise State jumped seven places to No. 17.
Chadwick would reverse those two.
He would also consider putting USC ahead of Kentucky.
Boise State is 9-1 and remains the highest-ranked Group of Six team, which currently puts the Broncos in position for the automatic playoff berth reserved for that group.
Chadwick sees No. 16 as a more appropriate range for Boise State.
Kentucky’s three losses and fading playoff résumé make the Wildcats difficult to justify above a one-loss Boise State team.
South Carolina Should Not Be Ranked
South Carolina remaining No. 21 drew Chadwick’s strongest objection outside Alabama.
The Gamecocks are 6-4 and just lost 34-6 at Arkansas.
LaNorris Sellers did not play, which gives the committee some context for the result. Chadwick doesn’t think it gives South Carolina enough of an excuse to remain ranked.
PFN’s strength-of-record metric had the Gamecocks 40th at the time of his reaction.
“I don’t really understand why South Carolina is in the Top 25 right now,” Chadwick said.
South Carolina has useful wins on its résumé, but a 28-point loss to one of the weaker teams in the SEC was enough for Chadwick to move the Gamecocks out entirely.
The Bottom of the Top 25 Is Much More Debatable
Chadwick is less concerned with Oklahoma at No. 22, Louisville at No. 23, Florida at No. 24, and Ole Miss at No. 25.
He isn’t certain Oklahoma needs to be ranked at 6-4, but the Sooners’ position is easier to defend than South Carolina’s.
Louisville is in roughly the correct range at 7-3.
Florida has four losses but owns enough quality wins, including Texas and Kentucky, for Chadwick to understand the Gators making the field.
Ole Miss also sits in a reasonable range after losing to Oklahoma.
The teams outside the rankings are where the conversation becomes more interesting.
Chadwick specifically mentioned Liberty and UTSA as teams deserving consideration. Liberty is 9-1, while UTSA is 8-2.
Neither has the schedule strength of the Power Four teams near the bottom of the rankings, but both have continued winning enough games to merit discussion.
What Max Chadwick Would Change in the CFP Rankings
Chadwick’s overall reaction is not that the committee produced a terrible Top 25.
Most teams are in approximately the right range.
His biggest changes would come near the top and at No. 21.
Georgia and Utah remain first and second. UCLA should move to third. Notre Dame and Miami should climb. Texas remains high but slides slightly. Tennessee should be above Alabama because of the head-to-head result.
Alabama is still comfortably a playoff team in Chadwick’s view.
It just shouldn’t be No. 3.
South Carolina, meanwhile, shouldn’t be in the rankings at all after what happened at Arkansas.
Those are the two committee decisions Chadwick finds hardest to defend as the regular season enters its final two weeks.
This article originally appeared on Pro Football Network.
Source: Yahoo Sports












Sign in to join the conversation.
Comments, replies, Roars, reports, and followed-thread notifications use your verified Rally & Roar account.
Sign in or create an account