COLLEGE PARK, MARYLAND - NOVEMBER 14: Head coach Luke Fickell of the Wisconsin Badgers watches the game against the Maryland Terrapins at SECU Stadium on November 14, 2026 in College Park, Maryland. (Photo by G Fiume/Getty Images) | Getty Images
COLLEGE PARK, MARYLAND - NOVEMBER 14: Head coach Luke Fickell of the Wisconsin Badgers watches the game against the Maryland Terrapins at SECU Stadium on November 14, 2026 in College Park, Maryland. (Photo by G Fiume/Getty Images) | Getty Images · Getty Images

The Wisconsin Badgers seemed to be trending upwards, but took a major step back this past weekend, as they lost 24-21 to the Maryland Terrapins, marking their second straight loss to Maryland.

The magnitude of this loss cannot be overstated. Entering this past weekend, Maryland had been 2-17 in their last 19 conference games. One of those wins was over Wisconsin last year. The other was to Purdue two weekends ago. And it’s not only that Maryland had been losing. They were getting humiliated.

Maryland lost by 51 to UCLA. They lost by 25 to Nebraska. They lost by 29 to Ohio State. A season ago, they lost eight conference games in a row after their win over Wisconsin, which included a 45-point loss to Indiana, 15-point loss to Rutgers, 18-point loss to Illinois, 25-point loss to Michigan, and a 10-point loss to Michigan State.

They suffered losses to both Rutgers and Illinois, but had started to turn things around a bit after firing Mike Locksley. Still, this was a game Wisconsin absolutely needed to and should have won.

And yet, Wisconsin failed to maintain any form of consistency once again after their 21-point win over Rutgers the weekend before. The Badgers are now 23-25 under Luke Fickell and 14-20 in conference play. That includes four straight losses to Iowa, back-to-back losses to Minnesota, back-to-back losses to Maryland, and losses to both Northwestern and Nebraska.

The problem isn’t just the number of losses. It’s also the way they’ve lost a ton of these games. Wisconsin has not been competitive in far too many games, and the theme has remained the same for four years. For whatever reason, the Badgers just cannot sustain wins and maintain a high level of play. Part of that could be attributed to the NIL era and how players aren’t bought into a program as much anymore.

But, at some point, the never-ending question surrounding Luke Fickell’s job security has to be seriously considered. Last year, there were several points where it felt realistic for the Badgers to think about moving on from their struggling head coach.

However, the Badgers administration believed the problem was the resources around Fickell and elected to invest even more money in the current regime, with reports alleging Wisconsin spent over $30 million on its roster in 2026.

With a much weaker schedule, I thought the minimum baseline for the Badgers would be eight wins. If the last three years had gone any other way, that baseline would be higher. And Wisconsin still has a path to eight wins if they beat Purdue and Minnesota, which is very realistic. But the questions that have been there for years around Fickell won’t suddenly go away if they win those two games, especially because of the Maryland loss.

So, is it time to finally make the Luke Fickell decision and move on after the season? Let’s discuss all the ramifications and outcomes.

Wisconsin’s 2027 recruiting class

One recruiting class can never make a coaching staff. But it’s hard not to point out that Wisconsin has returned to national relevance with its 2027 recruiting class after its 2026 class fell apart amid last year’s losing streak.

The Badgers have a bevy of blue-chip recruits and continue to add to their recruiting class with a couple of high-profile flips this Fall. We’re starting to see some of Wisconsin’s top recruits under Fickell really start to stand out.

The clear ones are linebackers Mason Posa and Cooper Catalano, who are both All-Conference-level players and are among the top defenders in the country. We’ve also seen some of the offensive linemen ascend quickly to be starters, although their development remains a work in progress, particularly as run blockers.

We’ve seen other pieces like Ryan Hopkins, Emmett Bork, Eugene Hilton, Darrion Dupree, Nolan Vils, Nicolas Clayton, Jai’mier Scott, and Cairo Skanes develop into role players for this team at some point this year.

There’ve also been a ton of recruiting misses, but the biggest positive of the Fickell era has been the high school recruiting classes.

Buyout + Coaching Candidates

There is the financial component to discuss when thinking about moving on from Fickell. The Badgers head coach still has a buyout of over $20 million if he were to be fired this offseason. That’s money you’re taking away from the roster, and that was the conversation that the administration had before retaining Fickell last season.

We’ve seen throughout the country that teams who have gone through this process with trying to keep coaches an additional year to avoid the buyout (most notably, Mike Norvell), and it’s very rarely worked, if at all. Instead, it’s just delaying the inevitable.

However, the bigger part of the decision is who would you replace Fickell with. Wisconsin is still a quality job with a mid-tier budget that ascending coaches can take advantage of, but it’s been well-known that this cycle is one of the weaker ones for coaching candidates in recent years.

Two names linked to Wisconsin by in-state connections are New Mexico’s Jason Eck and Wake Forest’s Jake Dickert. Of the two, Dickert would be the more ideal candidate for a situation like Wisconsin’s, but he just signed an extension at Wake Forest and, anyway, could be coveted by some of the top openings in the country outside of Wisconsin if he chooses to seek a new job.

Eck has been a very good coach at New Mexico, but it would also be a big gamble for the step-up that new Athletic Director Shawn Eichorst would have to nail. Eichorst’s decision with the coaching staff will probably be the biggest part of his legacy at Wisconsin. Chris McIntosh’s legacy was tainted by the Fickell move, which looked like a slam dunk initially, and his exit was obviously well noted.

2027 budget

The last part of the equation is the budget for Wisconsin in 2027 and how much that gets impacted by a potential coaching change and the buyout that ensues.

If the boosters are willing to pay up for the buyout while keeping Wisconsin competitive with a weaker schedule in 2027, then the move makes much more sense. But with the 24-team playoff coming up in 2027, the urgency to win is high. And Wisconsin needs to be financially competitive for that.

But once again, delaying the inevitable by kicking the can down the road and trying something that continues to fail to meet expectations is not the right strategy.

We’re in for another crucial offseason for the Badgers, as they continue to try and right the ship. Right now, they’re heading in the wrong direction once again.

Source: Yahoo Sports