
The up-and-down rollercoaster that has been Arch Manning’s college football career continued Saturday night against LSU, and Paul Finebaum seems to be enjoying the ride.
Prior to Manning’s first season as the Texas Longhorns’ starting quarterback, Finebaum labeled him the best college football player since Tim Tebow. Like most analysts who were quick to anoint him as the next great college football player or the next great Manning, Finebaum was forced to take the L last season.
But Manning’s career would peak again this season after leading Texas to a stunning 20-point fourth-quarter comeback against Ohio State. It dipped one month later when Finebaum declared it was time for Texas to bench Manning after losses to Oklahoma and Florida in back-to-back weeks.
And throughout most of Manning’s game against LSU Saturday night, he similarly looked like a quarterback who deserved to be benched, throwing three interceptions. But Manning proved to have a short memory, leading Texas to a game-winning drive, culminating in a touchdown pass with three seconds left in the fourth quarter. The resilience against LSU was enough for Finebaum to revisit his Tebow comparison Monday morning on First Take.
“He’s the gutsiest quarterback I have seen since Tim Tebow, I have never seen anybody put a team on his back after screwing up as much as he has” – Paul Finebaum on Arch Manning https://t.co/z0TqnDnRsg
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) November 16, 2026
“I took a lot of flak, and I should have, by the way,” Finebaum admitted. “For saying he’s the best quarterback we have seen – before we saw him really – since Tim Tebow. I’ll say this, he’s the gutsiest quarterback I have seen since Tim Tebow. I have never seen anybody put a team on his back after screwing up as much as he has.”
“That’s what you have to love about this guy,” Finebaum continued. “He does not run away from it. Unlike the coach on the other side (Lane Kiffin), he doesn’t make excuses. After the game, he said, ‘What people will remember was this drive, not my three picks.’ And that’s exactly right. In the moment, I have not seen a quarterback perform like this who is as flawed as he is.”
When Finebaum joined the Awful Announcing Podcast last month, the longtime college football commentator admitted he’s a big believer in “going for broke” when delivering an opinion on TV. And Manning’s young football career has certainly been a great place to welcome those all-or-nothing hot takes.
Arch Manning is not as great a college quarterback as he was initially hyped to be. Finebaum called him the best college football player since Tim Tebow; Dan Orlovsky labeled him a “generational talent.” Now in his second season as a starting quarterback, it’s clear Arch Manning is not that. But his up-and-down play over nearly two seasons has made Manning an even bigger hot-button topic. Because just when you’re ready to give up on him, he pulls off a fourth-quarter comeback or game-winning drive impressive enough to win back his believers.
The post Paul Finebaum dubs Arch Manning ‘gutsiest’ quarterback since Tim Tebow appeared first on Awful Announcing.
Source: Yahoo Sports












Sign in to join the conversation.
Comments, replies, Roars, reports, and followed-thread notifications use your verified Rally & Roar account.
Sign in or create an account