The penultimate weekend of the regular season gave us plenty to talk about. Three of the Big Ten’s top College Football Playoff contenders all lost, putting the conference at risk of potentially sending just one (!) team to the CFP.
We’ll have a better idea of just how likely that could be on Tuesday night, when the CFP unveils its fourth set of rankings. As always, I try to predict what we’ll see based on past rankings and comments made by the selection committee chair. It is not an exact science, and this particular committee has been inconsistent with its evaluation of teams even within its own Top 25. So, it’s no easy task.

Takeaways from College Football Week 12: Big Ten’s bad day, Clemson comes up big
The college football chaos continues, as Week 12 saw the Big Ten’s top two teams in UCLA and Indiana take road losses, Clemson quiet the noise after last week’s loss, Stanford return to the postseason and more.
- Nicole Auerbach,
This leads me to the million-dollar question: How much does this committee really love Alabama? The Tide’s resume has fallen off quite a bit as its best wins keep losing. Alabama has just three wins over teams .500 or better, and its best win is over 7-4 Kentucky. But the committee has given preferential treatment to the Tide dating back to its first set of rankings earlier this month. The committee has even ignored Alabama’s 16-point loss to Tennessee, keeping the two teams far enough apart that the head-to-head result doesn’t come into play as a tiebreaker. Could that change this week, with Alabama’s best wins devalued and Tennessee continuing to take care of business?
My guess is no. I’m sure CFP selection committee chairman Hunter Yurachek will come up with some word salad in an attempt to defend the indefensible once again.
It’s possible the committee considers moving Texas up ahead of Alabama — the Longhorns have better wins (including one over Tennessee on the road) — but again, I’m going to base my projection off the committee’s past behavior. And it has boosted Alabama despite these dynamics for weeks now.

03:17
How many CFP bids might the Big Ten have?
The College Countdown crew discusses how many playoff bids the Big Ten might have this season after No. 4 UCLA and No. 8 Indiana lost to unranked opponents.
I’ll be curious to see how far the committee drops UCLA. Last week, the Bruins were behind a one-loss team (Georgia) and a two-loss team (Alabama) despite being undefeated. So, that tells me the committee was already a bit skeptical of UCLA — both in terms of its resume and how it was actually performing on the field, since unbeaten Utah was treated differently. Last week, Yurachek said, “we've got a pretty clear understanding who we believe the No. 1 and No. 2 teams are.” That means Georgia and Utah. He then grouped the six or seven teams after those two separately.
I expect the committee to drop UCLA to about where it had one-loss Indiana (eighth last week, ninth the week before). The Bruins have a top-15 win over Oregon to anchor their resume, but they don’t have any other wins over ranked teams. And they’re down to their third-string quarterback. I would not be shocked to hear some of the same rhetoric we heard from Yurachek about Indiana’s resume and Indiana’s offense come up as he discusses UCLA this week.
Speaking of Indiana — I am predicting that the committee drops the Hoosiers out of the bracket this week after they picked up their second loss. Again, they have one top-20 win, and that’s about it. Three of their past four games have gone to overtime. Their offense continues to look shaky, and now they’re swapping quarterbacks and kickers mid-game. I’m projecting a five-spot drop for Indiana. I’ve got the Hoosiers behind three-loss Oregon because the committee just put three-loss Oregon ahead of a two-loss Iowa team that lacked ranked wins. I think the committee could do the exact same thing this week, arguing that the Ducks have a better win over common opponent USC and two other top-25 wins — and that the quality wins trump fewer losses. That’s the argument the committee made last week.

02:12
Indiana’s CFP hopes take hit after Washington loss
The College Countdown crew evaluates Indiana’s College Football Playoff resume after the defending national champions suffered their second loss in five games and saw their highly touted defense shredded by Washington.
Finally, I’ve swapped Wake Forest and BYU’s spots in the rankings. They’re both on the right side of the bubble, so maybe this doesn’t matter too much right now. But BYU needed three overtimes to beat a sub-.500 Kansas team, its sixth one-score game in its last eight contests. Meanwhile, Wake Forest has been the most dominant team in college football for the past two months and just picked up a sixth road win against a Power 4 opponent. The committee has been course-correcting on Wake the last two weeks, and I think that will continue this week, sliding the Deacs up one spot to reflect how well they’re playing (regardless of their relatively weak strength of schedule).

05:02
Wake Forest continues to dominate
The College Countdown Crew discuss how Wake Forest is a legit playoff contender who could possibly make the playoffs even with a loss in the ACC Championship due to the Big Ten’s recent struggles.
Boise State is not going to be ranked anywhere near the Top 12 this week, but I believe based on its strength of schedule it is likely to be the highest-ranked Group of 6 champion, which would earn it the No. 12 seed in a projected field.

College Football Playoff first-round byes
1. Georgia (projected SEC champion)
2. Utah (projected Big 12 champion)
3. Alabama
4. Texas
CFP on-campus first-round hosts
5. Notre Dame
6. Miami (projected ACC champion)
7. Tennessee
8. UCLA
Final teams in the CFP field
9. Wake Forest
10. BYU
11. Texas Tech
12. Boise State (projected highest-ranked Group of 6 champion)
First teams out of CFP
Oregon
- The Ducks have won four straight games since we all wrote them off. They’ve changed offensive play-callers and figured out how to get the most out of quarterback Dylan Raiola. Dan Lanning is back to going for it on fourth downs and calling fake field goals. This team is playing as well as anybody, and they’ve got three top-20ish wins on their resume. They could be very, very close to the right side of the bubble.
Indiana
- The Hoosiers will likely take a significant tumble after picking up their second loss of the season. Considering that the committee dropped Indiana five spots off a bye, there’s no telling what the drop could look like here. The Hoosiers have one top-20 win, but that’s about it on the resume. The Hoosiers could be on the wrong side of the cut line based on the way the committee treated Iowa a week ago. The committee put three-loss USC and then three-loss Ohio State ahead of the two-loss Hawkeyes because they had better wins. If that holds, Indiana could definitely be ranked behind the Ducks.
Nicole’s top questions for the actual selection committee:
- Has Tennessee finally done enough? The Vols beat Alabama, yet you wouldn’t know if from the way the committee treats both teams. But Tennessee just keeps winning, and the Tide’s best wins keep depreciating in value. At some point, the committee will have to compare these teams to one another and slide Tennessee ahead of Alabama, right?
- How far does UCLA tumble after suffering its first loss — and losing another quarterback? The Bruins’ best win is over Oregon, but they’ll likely have just one ranked win when the new rankings come out. The committee could also be concerned about the state of the offense moving forward with QB3. (We’ve seen the committee penalize a team with a great record because of a late-season QB injury before … cough, cough, 2023 FSU.)
- What does the committee do with Indiana? The Hoosiers have one quality win (over USC) and that’s about it. The committee has already picked apart their offense, their schedule … I could see them dropping them to the wrong side of the bubble. It would be consistent with the way the committee treated Iowa last week.
Source: Yahoo Sports







Sign in to join the conversation.
Comments, replies, Roars, reports, and followed-thread notifications use your verified Rally & Roar account.
Sign in or create an account