The Arizona State defense might be facing its most formidable challenge of the season this week. But maybe not.
The Oklahoma State Cowboys are rolling into town. The team is led by the top quarterback in the country, Drew Mestemaker, whom most project as the first quarterback that will be taken in the next NFL draft.
However, Mestemaker sustained a right shoulder injury in a loss to Texas Tech a week ago. He left the game with 8:07 left and did not return. His understudy is Broderick Vehrs, a local product out of Basha. The status of Mestemaker is the biggest storyline of the contest.
When he met with the media earlier this week, Oklahoma State coach Eric Morris called Mestemaker a "tough kid" and said he expected him to be ready.
ASU coach Kenny Dillingham is preparing to face the Cowboys' top attraction.
"He can throw with no space. He does not need space to throw," Dillingham said. "He doesn't need to step into his throws. He can throw in really, really tight spaces, and that's one of the hardest things to do, is to be accurate when you don't have space. He's a sneaky athlete. You know, you don't anticipate him going on a 60-yard run, and he can. The guy's going to run at 21 miles per hour when eventually somebody clocks him. That's what our little metrics have him at, so that'll give him some bragging rights back at home.
"And then he's a big dude, so he doesn't get a lot of balls tipped, and I think he has a really good feel for the system, so he anticipates throws. When you combine those just four simple things, you create possibly the number one quarterback taken in the draft, and that's the challenge for us this week."
Oklahoma State (6-4, 4-3) at Arizona State (6-4, 4-3)
Time/site: 8:15 p.m. MST, Saturday, Nov. 21, Mountain America Stadium.
TV: ESPN (Roy Philpott, Brock Osweiler and Sherree Burruss).
Radio: Tim Healey, Jeff Van Raaphorst, Kevin Turner, Jeff Munn.
Series history: Series tied 3-3.
Last meeting: The teams played in Stillwater in 2024, with ASU winning 42-21. That was a game that featured a two-hour weather delay at halftime. The last meeting between the teams in Tempe was in 2023 and was won by the Cowboys 27-15.
Other storylines
Oklahoma came into the season riding an 18-game conference losing streak but had new optimism with a new coach in Morris, who brought Mestemaker and 20 other players with him from his previous school, North Texas. Sophomore running back Caleb Hawkins and junior wide receiver Wyatt Young are among those.
The Cowboys were ranked as high as No. 18 nationally, with that coming in weeks 6 and 7. Then came a 51-49 upset loss at the hands of Iowa State. Two weeks later came another loss, this one to Texas Tech, that one thwarting any hopes of a conference title and College Football Playoff berth.
It will be the last home game for the ASU seniors. Most notable among those are three who have been with the program four years, as part of Dillingham's first class. They are RB Kyson Brown, DT C.J. Fite and DB Montana Warren. DL Blazen Lono-Wong has been at ASU for five years.
Coaching matchup
Kenny Dillingham, ASU (fourth year, 28-21): Dillingham, 36, was the Big 12 Coach of the Year in 2024, the season when ASU won the conference championship.
Eric Morris, Oklahoma State (first year): Morris, 41, came to Stillwater after three years at North Texas, during which his teams were a combined 22-16. He played wide receiver at Texas Tech from 2004 to 2008 and went back to work at that school as an assistant from 2013 to 2017.
Oklahoma State will win if . . .
It contains ASU rushing game: The Sun Devils' passing attack is still a work in progress with the true freshman Jake Fette at the helm. The Cowboys should try to take the run away, putting more pressure on a passing game that has been hit and miss. Oklahoma State is 86th in rushing defense, allowing 153.6 per game.
It holds up on third and fourth-down defense: Opponents are converting on Oklahoma State on third down at a 36.5% (55-for-142) rate. On fourth down they're even better, 14-for-25. It needs to get the defense off the field and its potent offense back on it.
The back end of the defense holds up: Morris acknowledged that passing defense has been the team's "Achilles' heel" so far. It has also had a knack for giving up explosive plays, with senior free safety Evan Jackson frequently picked on. The Cowboys are giving up 236.2 yards per game through the air.
Arizona State will win if . . .
The Sun Devils run the ball, control the clock: This is the most effective way of handling a team that is putting up video game-like numbers on offense. Keep the ball and minimize the opponent's opportunities. Oklahoma State is third in the country in scoring offense (42.2 ppg) and second in passing offense (334.9 ypg). ASU averages 137.9 ypg rushing, which is 94th out of 138 FBS schools. It will probably have to do better than that to secure the win, and it needs to be more than just Cardae Mack.
It doesn't let the game get away early: The Sun Devils are averaging just 28.2 ppg, ranking them 65th in scoring offense. They did rally from 14 points down to get even with BYU, but they haven't fared well in games where they dug themselves a big hole early. If they get into a high-scoring game with the Cowboys, it probably won't end up in their favor.
The back end of the defense holds up: You can't totally take a passing game like Oklahoma State's away, but you need to limit the explosive plays. This was a problem ASU had in some early games this season. Veteran Ashton Stamps is at one corner, but there is inexperience at the other. Senior Boogie Wilson is at one safety, and the Sun Devils have used a few different players at the other. Young players who could be challenged are freshman Daquwan Dunn and sophomore Jessiah McGrew.
Injury report
Oklahoma State: WR Dayvon Standard, TE Carson Kolb, DT Landon Dean are out. LB Tate Romney, OL Desmond Magiya are doubtful. QB Drew Mestemaker, TE Morgan McPhaul are questionable.
Arizona State: DL My'Keil Gardner, TE Khamari Anderson, LB Zyrus Fiaseu, DB Nigel Pringle, S Lyrik Rawls, CB Rodney Bimage are all out for the season. WR Omarion Miller and WR Harry Hassmann are out. OL Wade Helton is questionable.
By the numbers
0 —Number of games Oklahoma State QB Drew Mestemaker started at that position in high school. He played safety, punted and served as a backup at quarterback. With no scholarship offers and a belief he could play quarterback, he fought for a spot as a walk-on at North Texas. He moved up the depth chart as a redshirt, then started every game as a redshirt freshman and led the nation in passing yards in 2025.
4 —Consecutive games in which ASU has held its opponent to under 100 rushing yards. It ranks third nationally in rushing defense (59.3) and 22nd in total defense (293) over the last four games.
6 —Tackles needed for ASU LB Owen Long to reach 300 for his career. His 100 this season are tied for sixth nationally among all FBS defenders.
9 —ASU’s nine sacks over the last two games are tied for the fourth-most nationally. The Sun Devils turned 47.6% of their pressures into sacks, eighth-best in the FBS. Jalen Thompson leads the team with seven, while freshman Julian Hugo has 4.5.
63 —Number of tackles for Oklahoma State LB Tate Romney, who played for ASU from 2022 to 2025. The Chandler High School alum also has seven tackles for a loss, 1.5 sacks and one forced fumble. His single-game best was 14 tackles against Central Florida. He has missed the last two games with an injury.
They said it
ASU offensive coordinator Marcus Arroyoon Fette: "There are still some things where you're seeing some freshmen processing, or freshmen mistakes, which is pretty standard, but I think you're seeing a little bit here and there, the game slowing down, he's making some collective plays, he's making a play on his own.
Oklahoma State coach Eric Morris: "They're similar to us as far as where their season is. They're playing their best ball these last three games. They made a quarterback change, playing a young guy. Their defense has played really, really good, especially these last four games. It will be a big challenge for us, going in there and just the momentum gathering around this quarterback. They're playing complementary football. Nothing's been wow or sexy or anything like that. This quarterback, he doesn't turn the ball over, and they've found ways to move the football and score."
Who will win and why
Oklahoma State 34, Arizona State 24: This is not a season in which ASU is equipped to win high-scoring games. ASU is averaging 28 points a game, but that number is skewed by a 70-point output in the opener against FCS Morgan State. The Sun Devils have performed admirably on defense the last four games but will have to force multiple turnovers to give ASU a shot at the upset.
This article originally appeared on Arizona Republic: Can ASU football upset Oklahoma State? Here's why it won't happen
Source: Yahoo Sports











Sign in to join the conversation.
Comments, replies, Roars, reports, and followed-thread notifications use your verified Rally & Roar account.
Sign in or create an account