
The College Football Playoff committee made a choice on Tuesday night that leaves many fans scratching their heads. Georgia stays at No. 1 and Utah holds the No. 2 spot, but the real drama centers on Alabama. The Crimson Tide sits at No. 3 even after their three best wins all fell last weekend. Joel Klatt called the ranking “absurd” on his show Wednesday. He believes the committee is ignoring basic logic while building a closed loop around the SEC.
The Echo Chamber Problem
Alabama held its spot despite those losses. LSU, South Carolina, and Kentucky all lost their games over the last few days. Klatt argued that the committee is stuck in a feedback loop in which the SEC is tough because Alabama is ranked highly. He asked why South Carolina remains at No. 21 after losing by 28 to a 3-6 Arkansas team. Fox Sports reported Klatt thinks the answer is simple: they need to prop up Alabama. He compared the situation to a driver who took a wrong turn but refuses to admit it, just driving aimlessly through the woods.
The inconsistency is hard to miss for Klatt. Indiana dropped five spots in the previous rankings despite having a bye week. Klatt noted that all five of the Hoosiers’ best wins had lost, a factor he believes influenced the committee’s decision. This week, he pointed out, all five of Alabama’s best wins also lost, yet the Crimson Tide remained at No. 3. He argued that the committee was applying different standards to the two teams.
Big Ten And Big 12 Are Ready
Klatt believes the Big 12 has a legitimate chance to send multiple teams to the playoff. BYU sits at No. 10 and Texas Tech at No. 12, while undefeated Utah remains No. 2. He suggested that if Texas Tech beats Utah in the conference championship game, both could make the field, potentially leaving room for BYU as well.
The Big Ten is also lurking outside the playoff field. UCLA sits at No. 4, while Indiana is No. 8. Oregon, Ohio State and Iowa are ranked 13th, 14th and 15th, respectively, putting all three just outside the current 12-team bracket. Their remaining schedules and conference championship opportunities could still change the picture before Selection Sunday.
Texas moved up to No. 5 after beating LSU, but Klatt feels they are getting the short end of the stick too. The Longhorns have wins over Tennessee and Ohio State, while Alabama lacks similar victories. The committee released its third set of rankings on Tuesday, and the final 12-team bracket will be decided on Sunday, Dec. 6.
Source: Yahoo Sports











Sign in to join the conversation.
Comments, replies, Roars, reports, and followed-thread notifications use your verified Rally & Roar account.
Sign in or create an account