Nick Saban
  • Nick Saban named Georgia, Utah and Notre Dame as the three teams that can run the ball, play good defense and have a good quarterback, per CBS Sports.
  • Alabama coach Kalen DeBoer said Thursday that this is the most complete team he has had after taking over for Saban before the 2024 season.
  • College Football Playoff selection committee chair Hunter Yurachek said Tuesday the committee feels Alabama is one of the best three or four teams in the country.

A Former Alabama Coach and the Selection Committee See Two Different Teams

Nick Saban won six national championships at Alabama. On Friday he said the Crimson Tide are not among the three teams that have the right stuff to win this season’s title, though he put them on a longer list.

“Me personally, I think there’s three teams that have the right stuff,” Saban said. “This is no disrespect to Alabama because I think there’s probably seven or eight teams that could win the championship, Alabama being one of them, but if you’re a betting man and you say, who can run the ball, who can play good defense, and who has a good quarterback?”

“You would say Georgia has that, Utah has that. Notre Dame has that. Everybody else maybe has a flaw somewhere along the way. They might be able to overcome it, but I think those three teams have the right stuff.”

Saban Names Three Teams While the Committee Praises Alabama

Alabama has two wins over ranked teams, Kentucky and South Carolina, and three straight SEC wins after losing twice last month to Georgia and Tennessee. The selection committee has viewed the Crimson Tide more fondly than most contenders in recent weeks. In the third College Football Playoff rankings, released Tuesday, Nov. 17, Alabama sat third, behind Georgia and Utah, and two spots ahead of No. 5 Texas. Yurachek explained the thinking after the reveal.

“I think it’s a collection of things for Alabama,” Yurachek said. “Not only the margin of wins, their SEC wins, which is close to 23 points a game, but their relative scoring defense is in the top 20, relative scoring offense is in the top five, record strength is in the top 5. Quite honestly, when we watch them on film, when we watch their games, we really feel like they’re one of the best three or four teams in the country.”

“I mentioned their (Alabama’s) point spread in their conference games is close to 23 points a game, Texas is not in that same ballpark,” Yurachek said of Texas. “The separator for us as a committee between the two is just the consistent play of Alabama throughout the season.”

Saban, who recently spoke about Arch Manning, said the committee has a difficult job.

“I think (Alabama has) a good team, but it’s hard to say who should be ranked where, especially with the diversity of strength of schedule trying to be sort of instituted in this in a not so … I don’t know how you’d say it, but it’s very hard to do in college football,” Saban said. “There’s a big deviation in quality of play, quality of teams, quality of players. I think it’s very difficult for them to be too subjective about how they go about ranking these teams.”

DeBoer Says His Third Alabama Team Is the Most Complete

A day before Saban spoke, DeBoer gave his own read. Hired in January 2024 after Saban retired, DeBoer said this third-season group is the most complete team he has had. His message from the day he arrived in Tuscaloosa has been to “keep swinging and keep fighting.”

“I feel like we’re more complete as a football team and able to play anybody, anytime, anywhere,” DeBoer said. “But you got to go do it.”

Vanderbilt is his example. In 2024, Alabama lost there for the first time in 55 years, allowing 40 points and 418 yards. Last week the Crimson Tide won there, giving up 6 points and 223 yards, as quarterback Keelon Russell threw for 217 yards and three touchdowns.

“It was just a matter of moving forward and bringing together and me kind of meeting the guys where they were at,” DeBoer said of Year 1. “But I think you go through the experiences together and there’s more familiarity. The things that we’re executing now, it’s not a knock on those guys back then, but these guys have just had more reps together doing it. What we did defensively against Vanderbilt this last week was a lot of the same stuff that we made mistakes on two years ago. That’s probably the best example.”

The defense gives up 18.9 points per game, the 24th fewest in the country, and has forced 21 turnovers, the fourth most. Defensive tackle Terrence Green is back from a multi-week injury, and cornerback Zabien Brown, a Preseason All-American pick, is healthy again.

“You can feel it now,” DeBoer said of the defense getting healthy and the “presence” that Green, Brown and others provide. “And then other guys have gotten some experience now to where the rotations gained a little bit more depth there, too. We faced a tempo team with LSU and there’s a few more guys rolling in and out because we’ve built some of that depth up.”

The offense made the most of its chances at LSU and overcame some self-inflicted wounds at Vanderbilt.

“I think we were headed in a really good direction, and then just a couple moving pieces that weren’t consistent,” DeBoer said. “I think you’re always really close to being able to go explode and go do big things. And so there’s a little more continuity out there in the practice field [with players returning from injuries], and that helps. Guys should play with some confidence because a lot of times one play here, one player there that can give you that momentum that you need.”

“We got some talented guys and it’s just a matter of piecing some things together, putting some drives together like we’ve shown we can do,” DeBoer said.

Alabama also won 31-13 at LSU on Nov. 7, a 2:30 kickoff, scoring 21 unanswered points after Russell hurt his ankle and returned from the injury tent. That came after back-to-back losses to Georgia and Tennessee and a closer-than-expected win over unranked Texas A&M. DeBoer said the team stayed together.

“These guys got each other’s backs and they know each need to do their part and step up,” he explained. “I think that just fundamentally within the program, we have got ourselves to a point where they truly reset and they just know they got to go back to work, and they have enough trust and belief in themselves that if they do that the right outcomes will happen.”

“Now we have experiences together that we can draw on that make it even more believable,” DeBoer said. “And so if you just stick with it and keep playing, the things that you want to happen will happen. And so you got to go do it. You got to go make it happen. No one else is going to do it for us. No one else is going to do it for you individually.”

The Run Game Is the Open Question

Running the ball is the first of Saban’s three tests, and it is where Alabama has slipped. The Crimson Tide averaged 186.4 rushing yards per game through the first five games and 90.8 over the last five. Some of the drop comes from facing better defenses. Starting center Racin Delgatty and left guard William Sanders both missed time, and blocking tight end Josh Ford likely needs season-ending surgery after the LSU game.

“I feel like when Racin’s around, he really gets the direction set for us and the communication happens and there’s a good belief and confidence,” DeBoer said. “And so staying ahead is always helpful, and we can’t have the penalties. I think we’re just getting back to doing a better job there again this last week and we need to keep improving there too, not being in 1st-and-15’s like we were against Tennessee.”

Two Games Left in the Regular Season

Alabama hosts Chattanooga on Saturday and closes the regular season against in-state rival Auburn on Nov. 28. The SEC then plays its final championship game this season.

Saban put Alabama on a longer list but left it out of his three. The committee calls the Crimson Tide one of the best three or four teams in the country, and DeBoer calls them his most complete team. Alabama has two games left to add to the evidence.

Source: Yahoo Sports